Chisels Replacement: Top Picks for Every Workshop
For most woodworkers, the Narex Richter set is the top pick because it offers premium performance at a reasonable cost, but its handles may need reshaping for comfort.
Replacing old or broken chisels can be a tough decision. You need tools that hold an edge, feel comfortable, and fit your budget.
We compared seven leading chisel sets to help you choose. Each set has its own strengths, from premium steel to budget-friendly options.
Our top picks
Narex Richter Chisel Set (6 Piece)
The Narex Richter chisels feature high-alloy Cr-Mn steel for excellent edge retention. Owners report they arrive sharp and stay sharp longer than cheaper sets. The handles are comfortable for extended use, though some prefer to reshape them.
Pros
- Excellent edge retention
- Good balance and feel
- Comes in a sturdy wooden box
Cons
- Handles may need reshaping for some grips
- Higher price than other sets
Stanley Sweetheart Chisel Set (4 Piece)
The Stanley Sweetheart chisels are made from high-carbon steel with a classic design. They are favored by dovetail enthusiasts. The blades are thick and durable, and the handles are shaped for comfort. Some users note that the bevels are not perfectly flat out of the box.
Pros
- Classic design that works well
- Blades hold a good edge
- Comfortable handles
Cons
- Only four sizes included
- Bevels may need flattening
Irwin Marples Chisel Set (6 Piece)
Irwin Marples chisels come in a 6-piece set that offers great value. The blades are made from high-carbon steel and hold an edge reasonably well. The handles have a comfortable grip, but some owners report that the edges arrive not as sharp as expected and need honing.
Pros
- Great price for six chisels
- Durable blades
- Good grip handles
Cons
- Edges need initial sharpening
- Not as refined as premium sets
Husky Chisel Set (8 Piece)
The Husky chisel set is designed for tough jobs. The blades are made of hardened steel and are impact-resistant. The handles are robust and can withstand hammer strikes. However, the chisels are heavier and less suited for fine work.
Pros
- Very durable for rough work
- Impact-resistant handles
- Good value for the number of pieces
Cons
- Heavy and bulky
- Not ideal for fine woodworking
VonHaus Wood Chisel Set (10 Piece)
VonHaus offers a 10-piece chisel set that includes spare blades and a sharpening stone. It is a great starting point for beginners. The chisels are made of CR-V steel and are decently sharp. Owners say the handles are comfortable but the steel may not hold an edge as long as premium brands.
Pros
- Many pieces for the price
- Includes sharpening stone
- Comfortable handles
Cons
- Steel edge dulls faster
- Not as precise as professional sets
Felled Chisel Set (8 Piece)
The Felled chisel set is an affordable option for those new to woodworking. The blades are made of high-carbon steel and come pre-sharpened. They are lightweight and easy to use. Some owners find that the handles are a bit small and the edge needs frequent honing.
Pros
- Very inexpensive
- Good for basic tasks
- Lightweight
Cons
- Handles may be too small
- Edge retention is limited
DEWALT Chisel Set (4 Piece)
DEWALT chisels are built for job site durability. The blades are made of high-carbon steel and are heat-treated. The handles are impact-resistant and comfortable. They are a bit heavier than other sets, but they can take a beating. Some users report that the edges are not as sharp as expected.
Pros
- Durable construction
- Good for heavy use
- Comfortable grip
Cons
- Only four chisels
- Edges may need sharpening
What matters most
Side by side
| # | Model | Steel | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Narex Richter Chisel Set (6 Piece) | Cr-Mn alloy | Best Overall for Serious Woodworkers | 9.4 | Check price |
| 2 | Stanley Sweetheart Chisel Set (4 Piece) | High-carbon steel | Best for Fine Woodworking | 9.1 | Check price |
| 3 | Irwin Marples Chisel Set (6 Piece) | High-carbon steel | Best Value for DIYers | 8.8 | Check price |
| 4 | Husky Chisel Set (8 Piece) | Hardened steel | Best for Heavy-Duty Tasks | 8.5 | Check price |
| 5 | VonHaus Wood Chisel Set (10 Piece) | CR-V steel | Best Large Set for Beginners | 8.2 | Check price |
| 6 | Felled Chisel Set (8 Piece) | High-carbon steel | Best for Beginners on a Budget | 8.0 | Check price |
| 7 | DEWALT Chisel Set (4 Piece) | High-carbon steel | Best for On-the-Job Use | 8.7 | Check price |
Common questions
What is the best chisel set for replacing old tools?
The Narex Richter set is a top choice for its balance of quality and price. If you need a budget option, the Irwin Marples set offers good value.
How often should I replace chisels?
Chisels can last many years with proper care. Replace them when the blade is too short to sharpen or if they are damaged beyond repair.
Can I use the same chisels for wood and metal?
No, wood chisels are not suitable for metal. Use metal chisels or cold chisels for metalwork.
What sizes of chisels do I need?
A standard set includes 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, and 1 inch. Larger sets add more sizes for versatility.
Are expensive chisels worth it?
Expensive chisels often use better steel and have better fit and finish. They stay sharp longer and are more comfortable. For professionals, they are worth the investment.
How do I sharpen chisels?
Use a sharpening stone with water or oil. Hold the chisel at the correct bevel angle and move it across the stone in a smooth motion. Finish with a honing guide for consistency.
What is the difference between bevel-edge and firmer chisels?
Bevel-edge chisels have angled sides for tight joints. Firmer chisels have straight sides and are thicker for heavy work.
Can I use a hammer on any chisel?
Only use a wooden or rubber mallet on chisels with impact-resistant handles. Never use a metal hammer as it can damage the handle.
How do I store chisels to prevent rust?
Keep chisels in a dry place. Apply a light coat of oil to the blades and store them in a protective roll or case.
What is the best way to test a chisel’s sharpness?
A sharp chisel should easily shave hair or cut paper. You can also test by making a light cut on end grain wood; it should slice cleanly.
Our pick
If you need reliable, high-performing chisels, go with the Narex Richter set. For budget-conscious DIYers, the Irwin Marples set is a solid choice that won’t break the bank.
