Ice Trays That Actually Freeze Fast and Pop Out Clean
The top pick is the W&P Peak Ice Tray, ideal for cocktail lovers who want large, slow-melting cubes. Its main advantage is the silicone bottom that releases cubes effortlessly. The main limitation is that the tray is flexible, so it needs support when filling and moving.
Ice trays are a simple upgrade that can change your drink experience. The right tray freezes quickly, releases cubes without a fight, and fits your freezer. We compared popular models to find the best for different needs.
From classic plastic to flexible silicone, each tray has trade-offs. Some make giant spheres for whiskey, others make small cubes for lunch boxes. Here are the top picks based on specifications and owner feedback.
What we recommend
W&P Peak Ice Tray
This silicone tray makes 2-inch cubes that melt slowly, perfect for spirits. The lid prevents freezer smells, and the flexible bottom releases cubes without twisting. Owners report that cubes are crystal clear if you use filtered water. The tray is BPA-free and dishwasher safe, but it requires a flat surface to fill.
Pros
- Large cubes chill without diluting
- Lid keeps odors out
- Easy release with flexible silicone
Cons
- Flexible tray needs support when carrying
- Only 6 cubes per tray
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid
A sturdy plastic tray that stacks neatly with its lid. The lever releases cubes easily, and the blue lid snaps on to prevent spillage. Owners report that cubes pop out cleanly after a slight twist. It is BPA-free and built to last, though it takes longer to freeze than silicone.
Pros
- Durable construction
- Lid prevents spills and odors
- Easy release lever
Cons
- Cubes freeze slower than silicone
- Plastic can crack if dropped
Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Spout (2 Pack)
This two-pack offers stackable trays with airtight lids. The spout allows easy filling, and the silicone base releases cubes with a simple push. Owners report that the trays are sturdy enough to carry when full. They are ideal for making large batches for parties.
Pros
- Two trays for the price of one
- Lids with spout make filling clean
- Easy release from silicone
Cons
- Small cubes melt faster
- Silicone can retain odors if not cleaned
Glisten Ice Tray for Freeze and Easy Release
This silicone tray features a metal core that conducts cold, freezing cubes up to 40% faster. The flexible material pops cubes out easily, and the tray is compact. Owners report that cubes freeze in about 3 hours. The metal core makes the tray slightly heavier.
Pros
- Faster freeze time
- Easy release
- Space-saving design
Cons
- Hand wash only
- Metal core adds weight
Joseph Joseph Perfect Ice Tray with Removable Lid
This tray has a cleverly designed lid that converts into a storage container. The stackable design saves freezer space, and the lever mechanism releases cubes. Owners report that the lid fits tightly, preventing spills. The plastic is sturdy, but some find the lever a bit stiff at first.
Pros
- Lid doubles as storage
- Stackable for space efficiency
- Sturdy plastic
Cons
- Release lever can be stiff
- Plastic may stain with colored liquids
Tovolo Sphere Ice Mold (2 Pack)
Create large, spherical ice balls that melt slowly and look impressive. The two-piece mold opens at the top for easy release. Owners report that a clear sphere requires boiled water. The mold is BPA-free and dishwasher safe, but it takes up freezer space.
Pros
- Slow-melting spheres
- Easy to open
- Great for gifts
Cons
- Large size takes space
- Requires careful filling to avoid spillage
SUMPRI Silicone Ice Tray with Lid and Spout
This tray makes 15 small cubes per tray, ideal for lunch boxes or water bottles. The lid with spout prevents mess, and the silicone is flexible. Owners report that tiny cubes freeze quickly and are perfect for chilling drinks without over-diluting. The tray is stackable.
Pros
- Small cubes freeze fast
- Lid prevents spills
- Stackable design
Cons
- Cubes are small, melt faster
- Only one tray in package
The lineup, side by side
| # | Model | Material | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | W&P Peak Ice Tray | Food-grade silicone with plastic lid | Large cocktail cubes | 9.4 | Check price |
| 2 | OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid | Polypropylene plastic | Everyday freezer stack | 9.1 | Check price |
| 3 | Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Spout (2 Pack) | Food-grade silicone | Flexible silicone with lid | 8.9 | Check price |
| 4 | Glisten Ice Tray for Freeze and Easy Release | Silicone with aluminum core | Quick freezing | 8.7 | Check price |
| 5 | Joseph Joseph Perfect Ice Tray with Removable Lid | Polypropylene plastic | Stacking and storing | 8.5 | Check price |
| 6 | Tovolo Sphere Ice Mold (2 Pack) | Plastic (BPA-free) | Whiskey and cocktails | 9.0 | Check price |
| 7 | SUMPRI Silicone Ice Tray with Lid and Spout | Food-grade silicone | Bento boxes and small coolers | 8.2 | Check price |
What matters most
Questions worth asking
Why do my ice cubes come out cloudy?
Cloudiness is caused by trapped air and minerals. Use filtered or boiled water and freeze slowly. Some trays are designed to freeze from one direction to reduce cloudiness.
How do I get ice cubes out of a silicone tray easily?
Flex the tray from the bottom and twist slightly. If cubes stick, run the bottom under warm water for a few seconds. Avoid using sharp objects that can puncture the silicone.
Can I use any ice tray in the dishwasher?
Most silicone and plastic trays are dishwasher safe, but check the manufacturer’s instructions. Some trays with metal parts or delicate lids should be hand washed.
How long does it take to freeze ice cubes?
Standard trays take 3 to 4 hours in a typical freezer. Smaller cubes and trays with metal cores can freeze in under 2 hours. The temperature setting and freezer load affect time.
Are silicone ice trays better than plastic?
Silicone trays are more flexible and release cubes easier, but they can be less rigid. Plastic trays are sturdier and stack well, but cubes may stick. The best choice depends on your priority.
How do I prevent ice cubes from absorbing freezer odors?
Use a tray with a lid, like the W&P Peak, to seal out odors. Also, keep your freezer clean and store trays away from strong-smelling foods.
Can I make ice cubes with juice or other liquids?
Yes, but note that acidic liquids can stain plastic trays. Silicone is more resistant to staining. Always clean trays thoroughly after use.
What is the ideal size for cocktail ice?
For cocktails, large cubes or spheres are preferred because they melt slowly. They chill the drink without diluting it quickly. Standard cubes are fine for shaking or stirring.
The verdict
For most households, the W&P Peak Ice Tray is the best all-around choice due to its large cubes and easy release. If you want quick freezing on a budget, the Glisten Ice Tray is a solid pick. For those who prioritize stacking and storage, the Joseph Joseph tray is excellent. Avoid trays that are flimsy if you plan to fill them at the sink. Choose based on your freezer space and drinking habits.
