Garden Carts Built for Raised Bed Work
The Gorilla Carts GOR866DT is the best large capacity cart for raised bed gardeners, thanks to its 1200 pound capacity and deep tub that keeps soil and harvests contained. Its limitation is the 10 inch pneumatic tires, which can struggle in very soft mud, but on firm ground it rolls smoothly over grass and gravel.
Raised bed gardening means moving soil, compost, and plants in bulk. A standard wheelbarrow struggles with large loads and can tip on uneven paths. Large capacity garden carts solve this with deep tubs, wide wheels, and stable frames.
We compared seven popular carts that hold at least 500 pounds. Each has unique strengths, from dump features to all-terrain tires. Read on to find the one that fits your garden size and soil type.
The shortlist, ranked
Gorilla Carts GOR866DT 1200 lb. Capacity Dump Cart
This steel cart has a 1200 pound capacity and a quick release dump feature. Its 10 inch pneumatic tires handle grass and gravel. Owners report it moves smoothly even when full of wet soil.
Pros
- Huge capacity for large raised beds
- Dump feature saves time
- Sturdy steel frame
Cons
- Assembly takes about an hour
- Tub is not rust proof
Rubbermaid Commercial BRUTE 50 Gallon Utility Cart
This cart has a 50 gallon tub and a 1000 pound capacity. The plastic tub is impact resistant and easy to clean. Its 10 inch wheels roll well on pavement and hard soil.
Pros
- Lightweight plastic tub
- Large volume for its footprint
- Easy to clean
Cons
- No dump feature
- Hard wheels less ideal on soft ground
Jackson 500 lb. Steel Dump Cart with 10 in. Wheels
This cart offers a 500 pound capacity with a steel tub and a simple dump handle. Its 10 inch wheels provide stability. Owners report it is a solid choice for small to medium raised beds.
Pros
- Affordable price
- Durable steel tub
- Easy to maneuver
Cons
- Lower capacity than others
- Dump mechanism requires effort
Wagon Wheel Garden Cart 600 lb. Capacity with 16 in. Wheels
This cart features 16 inch spoked wheels that roll over rocks and roots. Its 600 pound capacity is adequate for most raised bed tasks. The tub is made of heavy duty plastic.
Pros
- Large wheels excel on uneven ground
- High sides prevent spills
- Stable on slopes
Cons
- No dump feature
- Heavier than other plastic carts
Lifetime 60305 55 Gallon Utility Cart with Dump Bed
This cart has a 55 gallon tub and a 1000 pound capacity. The dump bed tilts forward for easy unloading. Its 10 inch wheels are okay for compacted paths.
Pros
- Large volume
- Smooth dumping action
- UV protected plastic
Cons
- Wheels are not all-terrain
- Assembly can be tricky
Pella 800 lb. Capacity Poly Dump Cart
This cart combines an 800 pound capacity with a rugged polyethylene tub that resists rust and corrosion. Its 13 inch pneumatic tires offer good flotation. Owners report it is easy to push even when full.
Pros
- Rust proof tub
- Large wheels for stability
- Lever dump is easy
Cons
- Tub is not as deep as some
- Price is mid range
Wells Cargo 2000 lb. Heavy Duty Dump Cart
This cart is built for the toughest jobs with a 2000 pound capacity and a reinforced steel tub. Its 16 inch tires provide stability. It is wider and longer than most, so it requires more storage space.
Pros
- Extreme capacity
- Hydraulic dump makes unloading easy
- Very stable frame
Cons
- Large footprint
- Overkill for small raised beds
How to choose
The lineup, side by side
| # | Model | Capacity | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gorilla Carts GOR866DT 1200 lb. Capacity Dump Cart | 1200 lbs | Heavy hauling with easy dumping | 9.4 | Check price |
| 2 | Rubbermaid Commercial BRUTE 50 Gallon Utility Cart | 1000 lbs | Lightweight durability for daily use | 9.1 | Check price |
| 3 | Jackson 500 lb. Steel Dump Cart with 10 in. Wheels | 500 lbs | Budget friendly dumping cart | 8.8 | Check price |
| 4 | Wagon Wheel Garden Cart 600 lb. Capacity with 16 in. Wheels | 600 lbs | Rough terrain with large wheels | 9.0 | Check price |
| 5 | Lifetime 60305 55 Gallon Utility Cart with Dump Bed | 1000 lbs | Large volume with dump convenience | 8.6 | Check price |
| 6 | Pella 800 lb. Capacity Poly Dump Cart | 800 lbs | Durable plastic tub with high capacity | 8.9 | Check price |
| 7 | Wells Cargo 2000 lb. Heavy Duty Dump Cart | 2000 lbs | Massive jobs and commercial use | 8.4 | Check price |
Common questions
What size garden cart do I need for raised beds?
For raised beds, a cart with at least 500 pounds capacity is recommended. If you move wet soil, a cubic foot weighs about 100 pounds. A 500 pound cart holds about 5 cubic feet, which is enough for many tasks. For bigger jobs, choose 800 pounds or more.
Can I use a garden cart on grass?
Yes, but wheels matter. Pneumatic tires with deep treads work well on grass. Solid rubber wheels can sink into soft grass. Look for carts with at least 10 inch pneumatic tires, or 13 inch tires for better flotation.
How much weight can a typical garden cart hold?
Typical garden carts hold between 300 and 1200 pounds. Heavy duty models can handle up to 2000 pounds. Always check the manufacturer’s rated capacity and do not exceed it.
Are dump carts worth the extra cost?
Dump carts save time and effort when unloading soil, compost, or debris. If you frequently fill raised beds, a dump feature is worth it. For light tasks, a standard cart is sufficient.
What is the best wheel type for a garden cart?
Pneumatic tires are best for uneven terrain because they absorb shock and provide grip. Solid rubber wheels are maintenance free but can be hard to push on soft ground. For raised beds, choose pneumatic tires at least 10 inches in diameter.
How do I keep my garden cart from tipping?
Keep heavy loads centered and low in the cart. Do not overload beyond the rated capacity. Wider wheel bases and lower tub heights improve stability. When dumping, use the handle to control the tilt.
Can I leave my garden cart outside?
Some carts are UV resistant and rust proof, but prolonged exposure to weather can degrade tires and plastic. Store your cart in a shed or garage to extend its life. If left outside, use a cover.
What is the difference between a garden cart and a wheelbarrow?
A garden cart has two wheels and a large tub, making it more stable and able to carry heavier loads. A wheelbarrow has one wheel and requires more balance. For raised beds, carts are generally easier to use.
How do I assemble a garden cart?
Most carts come with basic tools and instructions. Assembly typically takes 30 to 60 minutes. You need to attach wheels, handle, and sometimes the tub. Follow the manual carefully to ensure safety.
Are there garden carts with removable tubs?
Some models allow you to remove the tub for easy cleaning or to use the frame for other tasks. However, most large capacity carts have fixed tubs. Check the product description for this feature.
The bottom line
For most raised bed gardeners, the Gorilla Carts GOR866DT is the best choice. It offers a generous 1200 pound capacity, a deep tub, and a reliable dump mechanism. If you have very rough terrain, choose the Wagon Wheel Garden Cart with its large 16 inch wheels. If you want a rust proof tub, the Pella Poly Dump Cart is excellent. Avoid the Wells Cargo unless you are moving massive amounts, as its size can be cumbersome in tight spaces.
