Top Oil Paints for Artists: Rich Colors and Smooth Blending
For most artists, Winsor & Newton Winton Oil Colors offer the best balance of quality and affordability, with reliable pigmentation and smooth consistency. The main limitation is that they are not professional grade, so colors may fade over time. For professionals seeking the highest pigment load, Michael Harding offers exceptional quality but at a premium price.
Oil painting is a timeless medium known for its rich colors and slow drying time, allowing for blending and reworking. Choosing the right paint can be daunting with so many options. This guide narrows down the best oil paints for various needs.
We considered factors like pigment strength, binder quality, and price point. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned artist, you’ll find a set that matches your skill level and budget.
What we recommend
Winsor & Newton Winton Oil Color Set
Winton is Winsor & Newton’s student grade line, offering good pigmentation at an accessible price. These paints have a buttery consistency and are ideal for learning color mixing. Available in a 10ml set of 10 colors, they are perfect for beginners.
Pros
- Affordable price point
- Smooth, creamy texture
- Good color selection for mixing
Cons
- Colors may fade over decades
- Not as concentrated as professional lines
Gamblin Artist Oils Introductory Set
Gamblin Artist Oils are a professional grade paint with a balanced consistency that works well for both thick and thin applications. The Introductory Set includes 10 colors, each with high pigment load. Known for their reliability, these paints are a favorite among working artists.
Pros
- Professional pigmentation
- Even drying time
- No fillers or extenders
Cons
- Moderately priced
- Limited color selection in set
Michael Harding Oil Paint Set
Michael Harding paints are handmade in small batches with the highest quality pigments. This set of 5 colors includes Titanium White and Cadmium Yellow, among others. The paint is incredibly rich and buttery, offering unmatched color intensity. Artists report that a little goes a long way.
Pros
- Exceptional color strength
- Handcrafted quality
- Minimal oil content
Cons
- Very expensive
- Limited availability
Utrecht Artists’ Oil Colors Set
Utrecht offers a professional grade oil paint at a competitive price. Their 12-color set provides a wide range of hues, from primaries to earth tones. The paint has a smooth, buttery feel and consistent quality. Ideal for artists who want a full palette without buying individual tubes.
Pros
- Large color selection
- Professional quality at moderate price
- Good paint flow
Cons
- Some colors may separate
- Not as highly pigmented as premium brands
Grumbacher Academy Oil Paint Set
Grumbacher Academy is a student grade paint that offers decent coverage and a glossy finish. This set includes 12 colors in 12ml tubes, perfect for trying oil painting without a large investment. The paints are easy to handle and blend well.
Pros
- Low cost
- Good for practice
- Easy to clean up
Cons
- Less pigment, more filler
- Colors may fade over time
Sennelier Oil Paint Set
Sennelier oils are known for their exceptionally creamy texture and intense colors. This set of 6 colors includes classic hues with high pigment load. The paint is made with premium safflower oil, which resists yellowing. Ideal for impasto techniques.
Pros
- Rich, vibrant colors
- Smooth impasto application
- Dries to a satin finish
Cons
- Higher price
- Limited set size
Rembrandt Oil Paint Set
Rembrandt oils are a professional grade line from Royal Talens. This 10-color set offers a traditional palette with excellent pigmentation. The paint has a smooth, buttery consistency and excellent lightfastness. Artists appreciate the predictable drying times.
Pros
- Trusted professional brand
- Accurate color mixing
- Consistent quality
Cons
- Small tube size in set
- Pricey for the amount
What matters most
How they stack up
| # | Model | Pigment Load | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Winsor & Newton Winton Oil Color Set | Medium | Best budget-friendly for students | 8.8 | Check price |
| 2 | Gamblin Artist Oils Introductory Set | High | Best for artists who value consistency | 9.1 | Check price |
| 3 | Michael Harding Oil Paint Set | Very High | Best for professionals demanding extreme pigment | 9.4 | Check price |
| 4 | Utrecht Artists’ Oil Colors Set | High | Best for artists seeking a comprehensive palette | 8.7 | Check price |
| 5 | Grumbacher Academy Oil Paint Set | Low to Medium | Best for hobbyists and new painters | 8.3 | Check price |
| 6 | Sennelier Oil Paint Set | High | Best for artists who enjoy a thick, buttery texture | 8.9 | Check price |
| 7 | Rembrandt Oil Paint Set | High | Best for artists who want traditional colors | 9.0 | Check price |
Common questions
What is the difference between student and professional oil paints?
Student oil paints have less pigment and more filler, making them cheaper but less vibrant and less lightfast. Professional paints use higher quality pigments and more oil, offering better color intensity and durability.
How many colors should a beginner start with?
A basic set of 6 to 12 colors is enough. You can mix a wide range of hues from primaries plus white. Many starter sets include 10 to 12 colors, which is ideal.
Can I mix oil paints from different brands?
Yes, you can mix oil paints from different brands. They are all oil based and compatible. Just be aware that drying times may vary slightly, but it won’t cause problems.
What is the best way to store oil paints?
Keep oil paint tubes tightly capped and store them in a cool, dry place. Avoid extreme heat or cold. Proper storage can extend the shelf life of your paints.
How long do oil paints take to dry?
Oil paints can take anywhere from 2 to 12 days to dry to the touch, depending on the pigment, oil content, and thickness. Some colors dry faster than others.
Are oil paints toxic?
Some pigments can be toxic, especially cadmiums and cobalts. Always check the label for safety warnings. Use good ventilation and avoid skin contact. Many brands offer non-toxic alternatives.
What is the best surface for oil painting?
Canvas, linen, and wood panels are popular. They should be primed with gesso to prevent oil from seeping into the fabric. Oil paper is also an option for practice.
How do I clean oil paint brushes?
Use a solvent like odorless mineral spirits or a brush cleaner. After cleaning, wash with soap and water to remove residue. Store brushes upright to maintain shape.
Final word
For most artists, the Gamblin Artist Oils Introductory Set offers the best overall value and quality, with professional pigmentation and consistency that works for many techniques. If you are a beginner on a tight budget, the Winsor & Newton Winton set is a solid starting point. For professionals who demand the best, Michael Harding provides unmatched color intensity, but at a high cost.
