Top Recycled Pencils for Eco-Conscious Writers
The best recycled pencil overall is the Sprout Pencil Plantable Pencil, ideal for those who want a zero-waste option, as it grows into herbs after use, but it costs more than standard pencils and may not suit precise tasks.
Recycled pencils turn waste into writing tools, reducing landfill and saving trees. They come in various forms: newspaper rolls, denim fibers, or plastic shavings.
This roundup helps you choose based on what matters most: sustainability, performance, or price.
How to choose
The best picks, ranked
Sprout Pencil Plantable Pencil
Made from sustainably harvested cedar and recycled paper, this pencil has a biodegradable capsule with seeds. When short, plant it to grow herbs like basil or mint.
Pros
- Plantable after use
- Strong eco-credentials
- Smooth writing
Cons
- More expensive than standard pencils
- Capsule may affect balance
Ticonderoga Recycled Pencils
Trusted brand with 100% recycled wood, these pencils offer consistent quality, easy sharpening, and a latex-free eraser. A workhorse for everyday tasks.
Pros
- Reliable performance
- Widely available
- Great value
Cons
- Recycled content may vary
- No unique eco feature
Dixon Ticonderoga Laddie Pencils
These jumbo pencils are made from recycled wood and feature a soft core that glides on paper. Perfect for little hands learning to write.
Pros
- Easy grip for kids
- Durable construction
- Non-toxic
Cons
- May break if sharpened too much
- Not suitable for fine writing
A Good Company Recycled Pencils
Made from recycled paper wrapped around a graphite core, these pencils feature a minimalist Scandinavian design. Comes in a set of 10 with a sharpener.
Pros
- Unique aesthetic
- Plastic-free packaging
- Smooth lay
Cons
- Paper wrap can peel
- Not as sturdy as wood
Pilot Begreen Recycled Pencils
Pilot’s Begreen line uses recycled plastic barrels and recycled wood for pencils. They offer a comfortable grip and consistent dark lines.
Pros
- Affordable
- Good quality
- Recycled materials
Cons
- Plastic component may not be fully compostable
- Limited color options
BIC Ecolutions Mechanical Pencil
This mechanical pencil is made from 74% recycled plastic and includes a 0.7mm lead. It offers a retractable tip and a comfortable grip.
Pros
- No sharpening needed
- Long-lasting
- Erasable
Cons
- Not fully recyclable
- Lead can break if pressed hard
TreeSmart Recycled Newspaper Pencils
Made from rolled recycled newspaper, these pencils are lightweight and surprisingly sturdy. A cost-effective choice for bulk use.
Pros
- Very affordable
- Uses paper waste
- Lightweight
Cons
- May feel less solid
- Graphite core may be off-center
The lineup, side by side
| # | Model | Material | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sprout Pencil Plantable Pencil | Cedar wood and recycled paper | Zero-waste gift giving | 9.4 | Check price |
| 2 | Ticonderoga Recycled Pencils | 100% recycled wood | Classroom and office use | 9.1 | Check price |
| 3 | Dixon Ticonderoga Laddie Pencils | Recycled wood | Young children | 8.8 | Check price |
| 4 | A Good Company Recycled Pencils | Recycled paper | Style and sustainability | 8.7 | Check price |
| 5 | Pilot Begreen Recycled Pencils | Recycled plastic and wood | Eco-friendly performance | 8.5 | Check price |
| 6 | BIC Ecolutions Mechanical Pencil | 74% recycled plastic | Mechanical pencil users | 8.3 | Check price |
| 7 | TreeSmart Recycled Newspaper Pencils | Recycled newspaper | Budget eco-friendly option | 8.0 | Check price |
Questions worth asking
Are recycled pencils as good as traditional pencils?
Yes, many recycled pencils offer comparable quality. The key is to look for ones with good lead and sturdy construction.
Can I recycle recycled pencils again?
Most pencils cannot be recycled curbside due to graphite and eraser. But some brands like Sprout are compostable or plantable.
What does ‘recycled’ mean in pencil manufacturing?
It means the wood, paper, or plastic used comes from post-consumer or post-industrial waste, diverting materials from landfills.
Are recycled pencils more expensive?
Not always. Some are comparable in price, but plantable or premium designs may cost more.
Do recycled pencils sharpen differently?
Some may be softer or more brittle, but quality recycled wood pencils sharpen like traditional ones.
Can I use recycled pencils for drawing?
Yes, many artists use them, but for professional art, you might prefer specific graphite grades.
Are there recycled mechanical pencils?
Yes, like the BIC Ecolutions, which uses recycled plastic for the body.
How do I plant a Sprout Pencil?
After the pencil is too short to write, insert it into soil with the capsule end up, water it, and watch it grow.
What is the most durable recycled pencil?
Wood pencils like Ticonderoga are typically more durable than paper-wrapped ones.
Are recycled pencils safe for kids?
Yes, most are non-toxic and safe. Check for ASTM or other safety certifications.
Our pick
For the best all-around choice, pick the Ticonderoga Recycled Pencils for everyday use. If you want a unique gift or a zero-waste option, go with the Sprout Pencil Plantable Pencil.
